Why Spurs fans face Arsenal dilemma

Why Spurs fans face Arsenal dilemmaFollowing wins over Wolves and Aston Villa, Spurs are looking to win three consecutive Premier League games for the first time since February 2025

They are the fiercest of rivals but will Tottenham fans really be praying for an Arsenal win this weekend that propels the Gunners towards the Premier League title?

Before relegation-threatened Spurs host Leeds United on Monday (20:00 BST kick-off), leaders Arsenal are at struggling West Ham in a high-stakes London derby on Sunday (16:30 kick-off).

Do Spurs fans want an Arsenal win, which will increase Tottenham's survival chances – and edge their north London neighbours closer to a first league crown since 2004?

Or do they want a West Ham victory – which will damage Arsenal's title chances, but leave Spurs back in the relegation zone before facing Leeds?

It's a nightmare scenario for Tottenham's followers.

"One of my Spurs mates said they would be cheering on Arsenal," Tottenham fan Ali Speechly tells BBC Sport. "I was like: 'What are you even saying!'

"Spurs fans are split over it.

"Personally, I wouldn't go as far to cheer on Arsenal. I couldn't bring myself to do that."

Spurs start the weekend with their Premier League future back in their own hands following back-to-back away wins at Wolves and Aston Villa.

With three matches remaining, last season's Europa League winners are 17th on 37 points – one more than 18th-placed West Ham.

If Arsenal and Spurs both win, West Ham will be four points from safety with two games left, while Mikel Arteta's Gunners – if nearest rivals Manchester City beat Brentford at Etihad Stadium on Saturday (17:30 BST kick-off) – will require a maximum five points from two games to win the league.

So, who do other Tottenham supporters want to win at London Stadium?

Unlike fellow fan Speechly, Bardi, from The Extra Inch, external Spurs podcast, says he can live with an Arsenal win.

"Right now, survival has to come first," he says. "This is our priority.

"Safety is more important than banter, but you won't see me crying if they draw 5-5 with Jarrod Bowen scoring twice in added time."

Spurs 'brave' with aggressive press – Micah Richards

Spurs have made two managerial changes since Tottenham last won a Premier League match in front of their home fans.

Since beating Brentford 2-0 on 6 December, Spurs have taken three points – all draws – from a possible 27 at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium under Thomas Frank, Igor Tudor and, now, Roberto de Zerbi.

After Monday's penultimate home game, Spurs go to Chelsea on 17 May before rounding off a dreadful season back home against Everton on 24 May.

"If we win our last three games then it doesn't matter what West Ham do," adds Speechly from Women of the Lane., external "But asking Spurs fans to feel confident in their team right now is a big ask.

"It's emotional gymnastics because a lot of Spurs fans had come to terms with the fact that relegation was going to happen.

"Now De Zerbi has come in and fans are like 'actually, we might survive'."

Two seasons ago Spurs missed out on a Champions League place after losing their final home game 2-0 to Manchester City, who went on to win pip Arsenal to the Premier League title.

"Life has a funny way of testing Spurs fans," adds Bardi.

"Many of us were happy to sacrifice Champions League qualification if it meant stopping Arsenal winning the league. That decision ultimately led to our great night in Bilbao 12 months later. This time, though, the stakes feel very different.

"Our problems are now much bigger than whether we play in the Champions League or Europa League. What is at risk is the status of the club, the future of key players, and the possibility of becoming the first founding Premier League club to slip into the abyss."

Shay Given discusses whether West Ham or Tottenham will go down

Bardi added: "Four weeks ago, I would have said immediately 'let Arsenal win. Our Premier League safety matters more.' I have seen Arsenal win titles before and could stomach it again if it kept Spurs up.

"But the turnaround under De Zerbi has changed things. For the first time in months, I feel like maybe we can trust Tottenham to manage their own destiny.

"A West Ham win could galvanise them and drag us further into trouble, so the ideal result for me is probably a draw. It keeps the title race alive, keeps West Ham behind us on goal difference, and means survival is still there for us to grasp ourselves."

What if Arsenal go on and win the Premier League – and Spurs go down?

"I don't think there is anything worse than that," says Speechly.

"If you are writing a script and you wanted to inflict maximum pain on Spurs fans, that's what you would write."

BBC Sport asked Tottenham fans on who they would prefer to win in the game between West Ham and Arsenal.

Here are some of their comments:

Paul: I can't think of a worse scenario for a Spurs supporter. On one hand, we need West Ham to lose, and on the other, a win for the Arsenal will move them closer to the title. A draw wouldn't be the worst result for Spurs so long as we beat Leeds on Monday, but that isn't a certainty, so I would rather West Ham lose and put up with the consequences of an Arsenal victory. Us avoiding relegation is the priority and I don't care about anything else at this point.

Kyle: Arsenal because it doesn't seal the league for them, but a Hammers loss and Spurs beating Leeds on Monday (fingers crossed) would mean a gap of four points with two games to go.

Rob: Any true Spurs fan will want our Premier League survival, what the other team achieves, although frustrating, isn't important.

Support Everyday Chronicle
Global reporting requires independent voices. If you value our coverage, please consider a small contribution to help us grow.
Click the button below to make a secure donation